Rental Property Investment Analysis
Investment metrics for 4925 Shirley Pl, Cincinnati, OH 45238
zillow
Single Family Residence
📍 4925 Shirley Pl, Cincinnati, OH 45238
$165,000
🛏 3 bed
🚿 2 bath
📐 1,456 sqft
18
/ 100
Deal Score
F
High Risk Investment
Grade F · 18/100
Monthly Cash Flow
$-115
After all expenses
Cap Rate
5.39%
Below 6% threshold
Monthly Rent
$1,072/mo
Estimated
Total Expenses
$1,187/mo
All-in monthly
Cash-on-Cash
-3.63%
Low return
Annual Cash Flow
$-1,379
Per year
Break-Even Analysis
Break-Even Rent
$1,187 / mo
Minimum monthly rent needed to cover all estimated expenses
Area Lifestyle & Investment Notes
- ▸Established residential corridors offer consistent housing stability that appeals to long-term tenants seeking quiet suburban environments.
- ▸Efficient access to major interstate arteries provides convenient commuting options for the local workforce employed throughout the region.
- ▸Proximity to diverse shopping and essential service hubs supports strong daily livability and enhances overall neighborhood rental desirability.
Key Takeaway
Investor Summary
Under current assumptions, this property is a high-risk rental investment (18/100) with a negative cash flow of $-115/mo. A meaningfully lower purchase price or stronger rent performance would likely be needed to make this deal work.
Analysis Summary
This Single Family Residence at 4925 Shirley Pl, Cincinnati, OH 45238 is listed at $165,000 with 3 bed / 2 bath and 1,456 sq ft.
The estimated monthly rent is $1,072, generating a negative monthly cash flow of $-115 after all expenses — including mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and vacancy reserves.
The cap rate is 5.39% and the cash-on-cash return is -3.63%. This deal received a score of 18/100 (Grade F: High Risk Investment).
More analyzed properties in Cincinnati
Run a BRRRR Analysis
BRRRR Deal Calculator
Pre-filled using this property's analysis. Adjust rehab and financing assumptions to estimate BRRRR returns.
Property Data
Rehab & Refinance Inputs
$
$
$
%
$
$
%
%
Share This Deal
Analyze Another Property
Paste any Zillow, Redfin, or Realtor listing to instantly see:
• Deal Score • Cash Flow • Cap Rate • Investment Risk